Doctors threaten Medicare backlash

Doctors threaten Medicare backlash

Posted using ShareThis
Doctors threaten Medicare backlash
By Parija Kavilanz, senior writerFebruary 25, 2010: 3:24 PM ET

NEW YORK ( — With a 21% cut to Medicare reimbursement rates set to take effect on Monday, the nation’s largest physician organization has informed its members about their options — which include shutting off practices to new Medicare patients.

“To our physicians, we are providing information on how to remove themselves from the Medicare program,” said James Rohack, president of the American Medical Association, whose more than 250,000 members include doctors, medical students and faculty members.

* Facebook
* Digg
* Twitter
* Buzz Up!
* Email
* Print
* Comment on this story

Dr. Priscilla Arnold warns that Medicare payment cuts could force some doctors to close up shop.

Federal law requires that physicians’ Medicare payment rates be adjusted annually based on a sustainable-growth rate that’s tied to the health of the economy.

Physicians face a rate cut every year, although Congress has at the last minute blocked those cuts from happening in seven of the last eight years and could still take action this year.

Temporary fixes aren’t good enough anymore, warned Rohack.

He said the AMA wants the current law to be repealed and a new formula used “that more accurately reflects the cost of providing care” in determining Medicare reimbursement rates.

In the meantime, physicians are asking the AMA to prepare handouts they can give patients to prepare them for the worst-case scenario: getting dropped completely. And a new report on the AMA’s Web site tells doctors how they can help their patients find other doctors if they decide to no longer accept Medicare.

“All this is a result of physicians becoming very frustrated with the situation,” said Rohack. “It’s regrettable, but it reflects the current political environment. Congress need a crisis before it acts.”
Dropping patients

Dr. Edward Kornel, a neurosurgeon based in White Plains, N.Y., stopped seeing Medicare patients two years ago. Two colleagues in his group practice have joined him in the past six months.

Kornel, who’s been in practice for 27 years, said he had always accepted Medicare patients in the past.

“But when I looked at my income from reimbursements, I was losing money every time I took care of a Medicare patient,” said Kornel. “It wasn’t covering my costs.”

While Medicare patients accounted for about 20% of his total patient load, they were generating less than 5% of his income.

“I would have had to do 300 operations in one year just to break even,” he said.

Still, he said he doesn’t want to turn away anyone who wants him as their doctor. “If they really can’t pay the fees then I will do it pro bono,” said Kornel.

The American Association of Neurological Surgeons, to which Kornel belongs, has warned that Medicare patients would likely get less access to doctors if Medicare payment cuts continue.

In a survey, the association found that 65% of its 3,400 members said they are referring their Medicare patients to other doctors. About 60% said they were reducing the number of Medicare patients in their practice.

“These results paint a bleak path we are going down,” said Dr. Troy Tippett, president of the association.

However, the federal government’s Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services said that its own data, and other industry reports, show that only a small percentage of beneficiaries unable to get physician access.

The agency maintains that 96.5% of all practicing physicians, nearly 600,000 doctors, currently participate in Medicare.

Dr. Priscilla Arnold, an ophthalmologist based in Bettendorf, Iowa, and past president of the American Society of Cataract and Refractive Surgery, isn’t buying those numbers.

“You have to assume that CMS’ data reflects physicians that are accepting Medicare patients but [do] not account separately for those who are reducing the number of Medicare patients,” said Arnold, who added that a majority of her patients are on Medicare.

She said she has to “realistically evaluate” every year if she can continue to see all her patients.

If this latest cut goes into effect, Arnold said many doctors in her specialty won’t be able to sustain their practices. “This year, the situation is more crucial than ever,” she said.

Kornel said consumers should prepare for some difficult days ahead.

“If doctors drop Medicare patients, these people will be forced to go to clinics where it’s hard to get appointments, the waits are long and you get far less attention than you would otherwise get,” said Kornel. “I think this situation is headed for disaster.” To top of page

2 responses

To state that doctors “threaten” Medicare backlash is bothersome. A “threat” implies something immoral or underhanded but what is being described is simple economic reality ie. drop the price on something through price controls and the supply of the service will drop. It is basic economics. How can anyone expect that physicians would continue to provide a service that produces a loss.
No matter what good or service you speak of, continuous losses leads to bankruptcy.
The solution is that doctors and patients should deal with one another on mutually acceptable terms which is the only moral non-coercive means that people should deal with one another. Medibid provides the means by which doctors and patients may do so.

Leave a Reply


Be sure to include your first and last name.

If you don't have one, no problem! Just leave this blank.