RSS Articles and Information
  • Economic Issues Delay Single Payer in Vermont December 22, 2014
    Gov. Peter Shumlin announced that he will not pursue a single payer health care plan this legislative session or in the near future, expressing “huge disappointment.” The Association of American Physicians and Surgeons (AAPS) applauds the decision. “Private medicine has …
  • Protect Your Children and Yourself from Phthalates December 19, 2014
    Phthalates are chemicals used since the 1950s to soften plastics. They are continuously released into the air, food, or liquid. How do you and your children become exposed to phthalates? Ingestion – When babies suck or chew on an object …
  • Holiday Specials on Lab Tests December 18, 2014
    Give the gift of health and wellness this holiday season. This is a great way to be proactive and keep up with your health as well as that of your loved ones. Below are the December specials from DirectLabs. You …
  • The Truth About Sugar December 15, 2014
    The past decade’s focus on low-fat diet has led to an unintended consequence, an increase in sugar consumption. Many people are not aware of exactly how much sugar they are actually consuming. The sugar, processed food, and beverage industries do …
  • Yet Another ObamaCare Miscalculation December 12, 2014
    by Marilyn Singleton MD, JD On November 13th, the Government Accountability Office (GAO) issued a report finding that that enrollment for the state-operated Small Business Health Options Program (SHOP), created by the Affordable Care Act, was significantly lower than expected. …
  • Ralph Weber Talks About Root Causes of High-Priced Healthcare – Video December 10, 2014
    The main reasons that health care costs so much are because of lack of transparency, lack of competition, and the complexity of the system. There is a lack of transparency between the patient and the provider, as well as between …
  • Here’s The Thing #6: Root Causes December 10, 2014
  • Yogurts: Not All Are Created Equal December 8, 2014
    by Adrienne Snavely Most commercial yogurts are full of artificial colors, flavors, and sugar, which stimulate disease-causing bacteria, yeast, and fungi in the gut. This overpowers your good bacteria, increasing the chance you’ll get sick. Healthier yogurts are pasteurized at …
  • The Scientist, the Sage, and the Homunculus: The Psychology of Direct Pay Medicine December 7, 2014
    How Patients and Doctors Make Decisions About Payment for Care. Dr. Robert Emmons and Dr. Josh Umbehr of http://Atlas.MD discuss the psychology behind direct pay medical care. From September 4, 2014, AAPS 71st Annual Meeting.
  • “The Rich, Fat Giant & the Free Market” – A Bedtime Story December 5, 2014
    by G. Keith Smith, MD When my children were young, I used to make up bedtime stories for them, stories they recently reminded me they remember even now.  I hope you enjoy the following actually true story, many versions of …
  • Hysteria’s History Episode02 FINAL December 4, 2014
  • Should You Worry About Phthalate Exposure While Pregnant? December 3, 2014
    Chemicals called phthalates are used to make plastic items more flexible. They are found in packaged foods and personal care products. In the past few years, studies showed that phthalate exposure put pregnant women at risk of complications and fetal …
  • Beyond Mere Board Certification: Paul Kempen, MD, PhD December 3, 2014
    Dr. Paul Kempen exposes the truth about Maintenance of Certification (MOC) in a presentation to physicians in the St. Louis area on November 22, 2014.
  • Health Benefits of Coconut Oil December 1, 2014
    Coconut oil is a saturated fat that helps you lose weight, decreases inflammation, fights infection, and protects the brain from Alzheimer’s disease. It works the opposite way other saturated fats do by improving the ratio of “good” to “bad” cholesterol …
  • Thanksgiving Special from MediBid for Physicians & Patients November 26, 2014
    Happy Thanksgiving from MediBid! MediBid is offering 25% off annual registration to give thanks to all of the freedom fighting doctors and facility administrators we have out there! We have a large group of self pay patients looking for quality …
  • Fraser Institute: Waiting Your Turn, Medical Wait Times in Canada 2014 November 26, 2014
    The Fraser Institute study, Waiting Your Turn: Wait Times for Health Care in Canada, is Canada’s only comprehensive measurement of wait times for medically necessary health care. Based on an annual survey of physicians practising in 12 specialties in each …
  • Why You Should Eat More Prunes November 24, 2014
    Many people are not fans of prunes, yet sales of “dried plums” are on the rise. Prunes have been a popular digestive remedy for decades with their fiber, stool loosener, and natural laxative compound. They are a sweet treat for …
  • ACA Architect Gruber Insults Voters November 21, 2014
    MIT economist Jonathan Gruber (an architect of Obamacare) has emerged in a handful of videos insulting the American public. In one video, Gruber discusses how voters’ “lack of economic understanding” enabled a politically unpopular tax on “Cadillac” health plans to …
  • Are You Vitamin D Deficient? November 19, 2014
    Many Americans believe they are not at risk for Vitamin D deficiency because they eat D-fortified foods. These foods do not contain enough Vitamin D to benefit your health. Vitamin D is not a regular vitamin, but a steroid hormone …
  • Ambulance Drones Could Help You Survive a Heart Attack November 17, 2014
    Heart disease is the #1 cause of death in the United States. The odds of surviving a heart attack outside of a hospital is only 8%. Four out of five heart attacks occur at home where there is no emergency …

The Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals Said VA Has No Standing to Challenge Obamacare’s Individual Mandate

Fourth Circuit Doesn’t Rule on Obamacare’s Constitutionality
Grace-Marie Turner
National Review Online: Critical Condition, September 8, 2011

September 8, 2011

The Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals said today that Virginia has no standing to challenge Obamacare’s individual mandate. In a second ruling issued at the same time, the Richmond court also said that Liberty University can’t challenge the law before the mandate goes into effect in 2014.

The latest rulings focused only on judicial procedure and not on the merits of the law, leaving a split decision between the Sixth and Eleventh circuits on the actual constitutionality of the individual mandate. (The Sixth Circuit in Cincinnati said the individual mandate can stand because it is important to the overall working of the law. The Eleventh Circuit — in which 26 states are challenging the law – disagreed and said the individual mandate is not only unconstitutional but “is breathtaking in its expansive scope.”)

In today’s ruling, the Fourth Circuit appeals court did not address the question of the constitutionality of the individual mandate: “Because we hold that Virginia lacks standing, we cannot reach the question of whether the Constitution authorizes Congress to enact the individual mandate,” the judges wrote. There was no dissenting opinion.

This is not a victory for the Obama administration. But neither does it help those opposed to the law.

In the barrage of cases against the unpopular health-overhaul law, the Eleventh Circuit decision in mid-August on the 26-state challenge from Florida was the most significant court ruling to date, with the panel saying the mandate is unconstitutional — a defeat for the Obama administration. The White House is weighing whether to request an en banc decision by all of the Eleventh Circuit judges in an effort to delay a U.S. Supreme Court hearing in the coming term.

Rather than basing their challenge on a state statute, as Virginia did, the 26 states base their argument on the individual mandate’s unconstitutionality as an unprecedented expansion of the federal government’s authority under the Commerce Clause.

In today’s ruling, the Fourth Circuit judges threw out the elegantly decided ruling in the Virginia case delivered last year by U.S. District Court Judge Henry E. Hudson, who decided that Congress exceeded its constitutional authority to regulate interstate commerce by compelling people “to involuntarily engage in a private commercial transaction.” Judge Hudson did not strike down the whole law but determined that the individual mandate and associated provisions could be declared unconstitutional – severing the “problematic portions while leaving the remainder intact.”

The Fourth Circuit did not address the merits, writing: “Article III of the Constitution confers on federal courts the power to resolve only ‘cases’ and ‘controversies.’ Specifically, a plaintiff must demonstrate that: (1) it has ‘suffered an injury in fact’; (2) there exists a ‘causal connection between the injury and the conduct complained of’; and (3) a favorable judicial ruling will ‘likely’ redress that injury.”

The court wrote: “Only if Virginia meets the burden of establishing standing does the Constitution permit a federal court to address the merits of the arguments presented. . . . Standing here turns on whether Virginia has suffered the necessary ‘injury in fact.’”

The court found that it did not, concluding “the individual mandate does not directly burden Virginia” and that it “does not threaten Virginia’s sovereign territory.”

Virginia attorney general Ken Cuccinelli had argued that his state has standing solely because the federal health law conflicts with a state law protecting its citizens from Obamacare’s individual mandate, litigating on behalf of the rights of its citizens. The court disagreed: “When a state brings a suit seeking to protect individuals from a federal statute, it usurps this sovereign prerogative of the federal government and threatens the ‘general supremacy of federal law.’”

It continued: “Given this fact, the [Virginia statue] merely declares, without legal effect, that the federal government cannot apply insurance mandates to Virginia’s citizens. This non-binding declaration does not create any genuine conflict with the individual mandate, and thus creates no sovereign interest capable of producing injury-in-fact. . . . Given this fact, Virginia lacks the ‘personal stake’ in this case essential to ‘assure that concrete adverseness which sharpens the presentation of issues.’”

The battles now move one step closer to the U.S. Supreme Court.

Posted on National Review Online: Critical Condition, September 8, 2011.



At MediBid, we restore market forces to medical care. Doctors get to set their own rates based on their training, experience, and outcomes, and patients get to shop for medical care across state lines and international borders. Many times with MediBid, you will find procedures that are more effective than procedures allowed, or covered by health plans. Transparency and competition are the only way to achieve reasonable costs. Many of our employer clients offering group health insurance through MediBid save $5,000 per employee per year. Those are substantial savings. Patients are saving an average of 48% vs. insurance discounted rates, or 80% vs. retail. Contact us for more information.
Share

Comments

This entry was posted in Health Care News, Health Care Reform, Health Care Repeal, Health Law and Legislation, News, Obamacare, Politics and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.
More Affordable Insurance AlternativeCategories
Bulk Email Sender